ConvertKit vs Mailshake

Hyperise integrates with 100's of sales and marketing tools, many of which are in the Email Marketing category. With so many to choose from it's sometimes hard to know which is best, but don't worry, we've got your covered.

In this comparison guide we're going to look at the Highlights, Pros, Cons and Pricing of ConvertKit and Mailshake. We'll also delve into the details of which offers the best personalization options within Email Marketing, with there respective Hyperise integrations

ConvertKit logo


Pricing: ConvertKit offers three pricing plans depending on the needs of the customer. The Basic plan starts at $29 per month and offers features such as unlimited forms, landing pages, and automation. The Professional plan starts at $49 per month and offers an additional suite of features, such as advanced segmentation, subaccounts, and an API.


Mailshake logo


Pricing: Mailshake offers three pricing plans: 1) The Lite Plan is $29/month 2) The Grow Plan is $59/month 3) The Scale Plan is $199/month


ConvertKit vs Mailshake Highlights

ConvertKit is a powerful email marketing platform designed to help entrepreneurs grow their online business. It has simpler, drag-and-drop tools, detailed analytics, and a focus on automating sales, opt-in forms, and newsletters. It also emphasizes sending targeted emails, integrating with other marketing tools, and providing customers with a unified customer experience. Mailshake is an automated email marketing solution that includes features such as email tracking and follow-up sequences. It was designed to simplify email outreach and to increase response rates. It comes with more advanced email personalization options, extensive customization options, and more sophisticated automation rules. It also has less automation features, a smaller library of opt-in forms and templates, and less detailed analytics. However, there is a log of customization with Mailshake and it allows businesses to automate many more follow-up emails.

ConvertKit vs Mailshake Pros

ConvertKit Pros

  • Unlimited email sequences: Workflows/ sequences let you easily send mails to your target audience in a specific order and time.
  • Better range of templates and customization options: Mailshake offers only static templates while ConvertKit has both static and dynamic templates.
  • Enhanced segmentation and tagging capabilities: ConvertKit lets you segment and tag your contacts in many different ways including by purchase intent, opt-in form response, engagement, and much more.
  • Autoresponders: Automatically reply to customer emails.
  • Integrations with other tools: ConvertKit integrates with over a hundred of the best marketing and ecommerce tools, like Shopify and Stripe.
  • Affordable pricing plans: Mailshakes basic plan is more costly than ConvertKits, which starts at much lower prices.
  • Flexible and simple user-interface: Much easier to use and set-up than competing platforms.
  • High deliverability: Banks on strict delivery standards to ensure high deliverability and even offers a money back guarantee on its deliverability score.

Mailshake Pros

  • Automation: Mailshake has an intuitive automation workflow that is simple and effective. ConvertKit offers more advanced automation capabilities, but they can be complex to use.
  • Pricing: Mailshake is cheaper than ConvertKit, making it an economical choice for small business owners.
  • Reporting: Mailshake provides detailed reporting on click-through rates, open rates, and other metrics, allowing users to gain precise insights into campaigns success.
  • A/B testing: Mailshake offers powerful A/B testing capabilities to help optimize campaigns for higher engagement and more effective communications.
  • Customer service: Mailshake provides excellent customer support through chat and email, with friendly and knowledgeable support staff on hand to answer queries.

ConvertKit vs Mailshake Cons

ConvertKit Cons

  • More expensive than Mailshake
  • More complicated and users with no technical background can find it difficult to use
  • Not as many organizational options (no folders or categories)
  • Scheduling of emails is more limited (you can only schedule weekly emails like a newsletter but not one-time emails)
  • Limited reporting on open and click rates unless you have a paid plan
  • Limited automation options when compared to Mailshake

Mailshake Cons

  • Mailshake lacks automatic sequencing, while ConvertKit has thorough automations
  • Mailshake lacks the ability to segment and tailor your emails, while ConvertKit offers powerful segmentation and tagging
  • Mailshake lacks advanced analytics and reporting, while ConvertKit offers extensive analytics and reporting
  • Mailshake lacks visual email builder and opt-in forms, while ConvertKit has a drag and drop visual builder and opt-in form builder
  • Mailshake lacks good automated email support, while ConvertKit has many built-in features to optimize automated emails

ConvertKit & Mailshake Hyperise Integrations

ConvertKit uses the HTML code embed method to integrate with Hyperise, giving a simple way to add personalized images to your messages.

ConvertKit makes the following data points available to Hyperise, to enable personalization in images used in outreach and linked out to your personalized website landing pages.

ConvertKit integration diagram
  • First name

ConvertKit Integration Guide

Mailshake uses the Image embed method to integrate with Hyperise, giving a simple way to add personalized images to your messages.

Mailshake makes the following data points available to Hyperise, to enable personalization in images used in outreach and linked out to your personalized website landing pages.

Mailshake integration diagram
  • First name
  • Last name
  • Business name

Mailshake Integration Guide

Other ConvertKit & Mailshake Email Marketing platform comparisons

View all Platform Comparisons

ConvertKit and Mailshake Frequently Asked Questions

Question: How does ConvertKit work?

Answer: ConvertKit is an email marketing platform that provides a suite of powerful tools to help you grow your digital business. It allows you to easily create and manage automation workflows, share content with your subscribers, and analyze your progress.

Question: What happens when I exceed my subscriber limit?

Answer: Once you exceed your current limits, ConvertKit will upgrade your plan to the next level. You can always adjust your plan as needed.

Question: What payment options are available?

Answer: ConvertKit offers a variety of payment options, including all major credit cards and PayPal.

ConvertKit vs Mailshake

Question: What does ConvertKit do?

Answer: Convertkit is the ultimate marketing tool for automation. It lets users create easy forms and drip campaigns to automatically send mails to new subscribers, while delivering a simple solution for any other campaign needs that you may have as well!

Question: What’s the ConvertKit Community all about?

Answer: Just click the ‘Community’ link from the dropdown menu, accessible on any page in your ConvertKit account. A new community will be created for you using your existing login details and a place to jump right into our vibrant online space! We’re around each day answering questions/providing resources so come find us at anytime with whatever is weighing on your mind. Once inside group chat, make sure to ask about getting support or information specific to what type of creator you are (e.g. blogger).

Question: What is a sequence?

Answer: Sequences are a fun way to keep in touch with your subscribers. Sequences allow you to send automated emails on set schedules directly from the Dashboard or API, and they’re perfect for giving regular updates about new blog posts or other content that may interest them most. They can also be used as an easy reminder service - get automatic notifications when someone subscribes using this sequence! Sequence is self-contained sets of automated emails where subscribers follow through each email sequentially starting at the first one sent since their addition into the list (in relation with time). Send times are relative between all sequences which means if there’s any delay before sending out messages; it will take longer for recipients who were added after others because those ones have been waiting.

Question: What’s the difference between a sequence and a broadcast?

Answer: Sequences are the perfect tool for creating automated, evergreen-style content. They allow you to put together a sequence of emails that’s powered by one central theme and send them out on a set schedule - making it easy for your readers to get daily or weekly updates from you! Broadcasts might seem like they’re just used in more targeted email sequences but actually have their own purpose too: if there is something important going down, use broadcasts as an opportunity help make sure everyone who needs this information has access to it right away!

Question: What is an automation?

Answer: Automations are a way for you to create an automated path through your account. Think of them as maps, guiding the subscribers from one place in your account (destination) to another along their journey with you!

Question: What is a link trigger?

Answer: Link triggers are like a link with an extra perk. Linking to your email series will automatically subscribe the reader when they click on it, and you can use this power for more than just posting links! Add tags or even sets of emails in one fell swoop by setting up some smart-triggers all at once. It’s so fast that we’re thinking of renaming them link shortcuts! To create a link trigger in your account click the ‘Add Rule’ button in the Rules page. Then, under Trigger select ‘Clicks a Link’ and give your link trigger a name and destination URL. You can then select an action for the trigger, such as add a tag, or trigger a sequence etc. Save your new rule and you’re done!

Question: How do I get started with Mailshake?

Answer: You'll need to create an account and purchase a plan before starting. Then, you can begin creating campaigns, uploading contacts, and launching your first outreach.

Question: Is there a free trial?

Answer: Yes, you can use our free trial to explore the features before purchasing.

Question: What types of campaigns are available?

Answer: Mailshake offers campaigns for cold outreach, follow-up sequences, event invites, referrals, and reviews.

Question: Is there a limit on how many messages I can send?

Answer: Yes, there are limits imposed by Mailshake to ensure a positive user experience.

Question: What support does Mailshake offer?

Answer: We offer full technical support via email and live chat, as well as helpful resources and articles in our Help Center.